| Year | Champions | Score | Host Course |
|---|
| 2020 |
KJ Stutz & Rocky Bare |
63 |
Pilgrim's Oak |
| 2019 |
Craig Kliewer & Alan Kliewer |
63 |
Meadia Heights |
| 2018 |
Corey Gast & Brett Kendig |
62 |
Highlands of Donegal |
| 2017 |
Trevor Pope & Jarred Texter |
59 |
Conestoga |
| 2016 |
Mark Leaman & Joe Klazas |
62 |
Crossgates |
| 2015 |
Connor Sheehan & Derek McCarty |
61 |
Overlook |
| 2014 |
Matt Burkhart & Shane Glackin |
59 |
Tanglewood |
| 2013 |
Casey & Greg Osborne |
58 |
Overlook |
| 2012 |
Rick Wise & Chance Miller |
59 |
Bent Creek |
| 2011 |
Matt & Mike Burkhart |
60 |
Crossgates |
| 2010 |
Matt & Mike Burkhart |
60 |
Lancaster Host |
| 2009 |
Ben Smith & Rob Campbell |
61 |
Pilgrim's Oak |
| 2008 |
Dave Richards & Greg Osborne |
59 |
Four Seasons |
| 2007 |
Deryl Denlinger & Andy Tompos |
59 |
Overlook |
| 2006 |
Dan Price & Dan Walters |
58 |
Crossgates |
| 2005 |
Brandon & Marlin Detweiler |
59 |
Groff's Farm |
| 2004 |
Corey Gast & Ron Weaver |
60 |
Tanglewood |
| 2003 |
Dan Walters & Ron Weaver |
61 |
Foxchase |
| 2002 |
Trey Egan & Greg Osborne |
61 |
Hawk Valley |
| 2001 |
Marlin Detweiler & Ron Weaver |
60 |
Lancaster Host |
| 2000 |
Brian Groff & Marty Sowa |
61 |
Four Seasons |
| 1999 |
Steve Dyer & Jay Filling |
62 |
Bent Creek |
| 1998 |
Marlin Detweiler & Hank Kline |
61 |
Crossgates |
| 1997 |
Tom Dell & Scott Van Gordon |
64 |
Tanglewood |
| 1996 |
Deryl Denlinger & Andy Tompos |
63 |
Lancaster Host |
| 1995 |
John Gamby & Doug Hallman |
63 |
Conestoga |
| 1994 |
John Moyer & Jeff Wintersteen |
63 |
Meadia Heights |
