| Year | Champion | Score | Host Course |
|---|
| 2020 |
Tyler Wassell defeats Chris Fieger |
1 up 19 |
Crossgates GC |
| 2019 |
Shaun Fedor defeats Brook Fassnacht |
1 up 21 |
Conestoga CC |
| 2018 |
Brandon Detweiler defeats Chris Fieger |
|
Lancaster CC |
| 2017 |
Chris Fieger defeats Jared Texter |
4&3 |
Lancaster CC |
| 2016 |
Chris Fieger defeats Brandon Detweiler |
1 up |
Lancaster CC |
| 2015 |
David Denlinger defeats Connor Sheehan |
5&3 |
Meadia Heights |
| 2014 |
David Denlinger defeats Mike Turner |
5&4 |
Lancaster CC |
| 2013 |
Corey Gast defeats Chris Feiger |
3&1 |
Lancaster CC |
| 2012 |
Zak Drescher defeats Craig Hornberger |
3&1 |
Highlands of Donegal |
| 2011 |
Corey Gast defeats Craig Hornberger |
19 holes |
Bent Creek |
| 2010 |
David Denlinger defeats Andrew Arnold |
20 Holes |
Foxchase |
| 2009 |
Corey Gast defeats Trent Coldren |
2&1 |
Overlook |
